Bursting at the seams: Hamilton County animal shelter dangerously overcrowded


The Humane Society’s shelter is full to the brim, prompting the need for foster homes and possibly a new facility

By Adam Aasen

Despite her problems, Jade is a happy dog. She might not have any teeth, but she still has a big smile.

This black pit bull had her teeth pulled out by her previous owner when they forced her to breed. She’s covered with scars from past injuries and very large tumors. Despite her traumatic life, she absolutely loves people and sniffs anybody that passes by.

But Jade is afraid of other dogs, so she spends her days in the office of Rebecca Stevens, executive director of the Humane Society for Hamilton County. That’s because there’s literally no other space for this sick dog.

And this isn’t a unique situation.

The shelter – the only one for the entire county – is extremely full. One cat that has leukemia lives in their conference room. The problem is compounded by the fact that there’s no area to quarantine sick or contagious animals.

Take a tour and people will see there’s no wasted space.

“There’s an animal everywhere,” Stevens said. “We are dealing with a lot of serious challenges in a lot of areas, but we are trying to overcome them to the best of our abilities and save these lives.”

The Humane Society for Hamilton County is still committed to remaining a no-kill shelter, which means they only euthanize pets in extreme situations. They don’t turn away any intakes, even if the shelter doesn’t have room.

As a result, there’s a huge reliance on using foster homes for nearly half the dogs and cats in their care.

At their May board meeting, there was talk about fundraising for a new larger facility. There have been no public announcements, but they are looking to launch a capital campaign to raise up to $7 million.

Overflowing with pets

At the end of May, there were 219 cats in the shelter’s care, 101 in foster homes and 113 dogs in their care, 32 in foster homes.

The animals are dealing with upper respiratory infections and eye infections because the pets are kept in such close quarters that it’s difficult to avoid spreading illnesses.

As a result, the shelter spends more than $100,000 on medical care, a cost that is entirely paid for through private donations and not from taxpayer money.

When a dog or cat is admitted, larger shelters would put them into an intake area to run tests to make sure no diseases are introduced. In Hamilton County, there’s no space, so that can affect medical costs and the ability to adopt out ill pets.

Stevens said many people are surprised to hear about this problem here in the suburbs. People assume that stray pets and crowded animal shelters are an urban issue, but there are so many pets per capita that the issue exists north of the border 96th Street border, as well.

Some of Hamilton County’s elderly people pass away or are unable to care for pets anymore. Sometimes people in Indianapolis will take advantage of the shelter’s unique no-kill, open-admission policy and drive up to drop them off.

There is a county ordinance that mandates spaying and neutering if you don’t have a breeder’s license. It helps lessen the impact, but it can be hard to enforce.

Finding a foster family

Charlene Kallach fell into fostering when she was volunteering at the shelter and saw a sick cat named George who was only expected to live for two weeks.

“I said, ‘If he’s going to die, at least he’ll be in a loving home.’”

George ended up living much longer. The cat began to walk again, using the litter box and feeding itself. Eventually he was adopted, which Kallach found so rewarding that she was then hooked on fostering.

Stevens said foster homes are an absolute necessity to remain no-kill and open admission, but it can be hard to recruit new people. There are so many roadblocks.

Some people are afraid they will get too attached and won’t be able to give up the pet. Some dogs and cats have special needs, such as problems with other animals. And of course there are many misconceptions, such as cost.

But the shelter pays for any expenses such as medical care, crates, food and even kitty litter.

“It doesn’t cost you any money or a lot of your time. All you need to provide is love,” said Paula Fuccillo, who is currently fostering a border collie who was attacked by other dogs and has a broken leg.

Fostering is not only important to help alleviate overcrowding, but some sick or scared animals need the space and comfort to heal and become more adoptable.

One cat available right now is Faith, a multi-colored feline who had painful bone fractures in every toe as a result of a botched declawing.

Fundraising for the future

Stevens said one common misconception is that the county pays for all of the shelter’s costs. In reality, taxpayer dollars only cover the first seven days that an animal is in the shelter. From then on, all of the rest of the financial support comes from private donations.

If a dog is hit by a car, the entirety of that cost is privately funded. As a result, the Humane Society is always looking for new donors.

The cost per animal averages out to be about $8.50 per day.

Because there are so many costs, most of the donations go toward basic needs. Recently, there wasn’t even air conditioning in the hot garage where dogs are kenneled. One dog suffered heat stroke as temperatures reached upwards of 90 degrees.

They were using a portable unit, but that died. Fortunately, a donor stepped up with $10,000 to install a new air conditioning system.

Americana Bank sponsors the foster program and helps pay for the associated costs. And Carmel City Councilor Kevin “Woody” Rider donates all of the gravel for the outdoor play areas.

But the biggest challenge will be raising money for a new shelter.

Stevens said it can be a politically sensitive issue so she’s enlisted the help of Carmel City Councilor Luci Snyder to help navigate those waters.

Snyder said the biggest help would be finding someone to donate land for the approximately 20,000 square-foot facility. She said they are open to most locations.

“Maybe there’s someone out there with five acres of land that isn’t really sellable but would be perfect for our needs,” she said.

The Humane Society is looking to spend $5,000 on a consultant to help determine the needs for the new shelter. They are also looking at hiring a professional fundraiser for the project.

Some people might think the solution is just to change the no-kill policy to alleviate overcrowding, but Stevens doesn’t see that as an option. She appreciates everything the county has done, but she said she needs more space.

“This was a great building when we moved in in 2006 but from day one that we moved in we didn’t have enough space,” she said. “The building is designed for an animal control facility that would euthanize dogs and cats, but we are a no-kill organization and we do not want to change that.”

Benefits of more space

Rebecca Stevens, executive director of the Humane Society for Hamilton County, said that with more space the organization could

● Cut down on illnesses spreading, which would save money.

● Dedicate space to addressing behavioral problems, which means pets are more adoptable.

● Expand their current program that provides pets for military veterans with post-traumatic stress disorder.

● Provide services that generate needed revenue, such as camps and training courses.

Get involved

To find out about how to foster a pet or donate to the Humane Society for Hamilton County visit www.hamiltonhumane.com.